In my opinion, this is incredibly clever, though only if done right. In some cases, it really slaps us in the face with reality. We as humans tend to believe that we are the most important species in the world. However, portraying humans as animals, in a way, brings us down to their level and shows how perhaps our problems aren't as big as we may think as we are only one of millions of species of animals living on Earth. Another ingenious use of animal characters is the incorporating of hidden meanings in works. One excellent example is Animal Farm, which criticized many people and ideas, all hidden in the animals. Yet another advantage to using animal characters is the ability to describe characters without actually stating it. If someone is drawn as a fox, it is implied that he is sly and cunning. If someone else is drawn as a hippo, it could mean that they are lazy and slow. There are also animals that are more up for interpretation. For example, if I portrayed someone as my bird, some may think he is cute and cuddly, while someone else may believe he is loud and nippy. This gives a book a unique element to it, with every reader thinking of the animals in different ways. The new effects and ideas that using animal characters instead of human characters create are endless.
Sunday, September 30, 2018
Animal World
It would be hard to imagine what life would be like without other animals. Even the most passionate meat-eater would have to convert to vegetarianism. We would have no loving dogs by our side. Other animals have become so integrated into our lives that they have even become an essential part of some books. This is just one of the "huge range of human experiences that can be portrayed...in either words or pictures", as Scott McCloud puts it in Understanding Comics. Sometimes, using animals as characters can create different and possibly even more effective feelings. One of these books is Maus, which portrays people of different countries and religions as different types of animals.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Cautious vs. Ridiculous
Is there a line between being cautious about something and being flat-out unreasonable? There have been many different topics over the years...
I love how you connected the idea of portraying animals as characters to the thoughts of McCloud and his ideas involving comics. I agree with you that depicting animals is more meaningful, but I also think that it creates a new kind of alternate universe for us to reflect on and see how our world would function differently.
ReplyDeleteEdison, I agree that using animals as characters simplifies many of the elements of a story. I also think that using animals detaches the reader from receiving the full impact of the real details, which can be a good thing and a bad thing. It may be easier to talk about sensitive topics with animals, but it could also keep the reader from fully grasping the effect of that story.
ReplyDeleteI like your relation of perspective to the different uses of animals in stories. Using animals to substitute humans or other beings in stories really does effectively leave a lot up to interpretation since everyone has had different experiences that can change the way they think about animals etc.
ReplyDelete